This paper presents a reliability assessment of the robustness of reinforced concrete moment-resisting frames subjected to sudden column removal. Two progressive collapse scenarios are considered, involving the loss of a central and a second-to-last supporting column. Three different frame configurations are analysed: a reference frame designed according to current seismic code provisions and two alternative configurations characterized by robustness improvements in the reinforcement detailing. A strain-based five-step procedure is adopted to evaluate the conditional probability of collapse given local damage (i.e., the removal of a supporting column). The methodology combines nonlinear finite-element (NLFE) 2D modelling with a full probabilistic framework, accounting for uncertainties in material properties and applied loads. Latin Hypercube Sampling is employed to generate 100 realizations for each frame configuration and failure scenario, resulting in a total of 600 analyses. Displacement-controlled pushdown NLFE analyses are first performed to derive probabilistic capacity curves, which are subsequently used to compute energy-based dynamic amplification factors through an energetic equivalence approach. Dynamic effects associated with sudden column loss are then reproduced by means of probabilistic static-equivalent NLFE analyses, in which gravity loads acting on the spans adjacent to the removed column are amplified according to the corresponding dynamic amplification factors. Peak strain demands in concrete and reinforcing steel are monitored at critical sections and treated in probabilistic terms. Failure probabilities and corresponding reliability indices at the ultimate limit state are finally evaluated. Given the lack of explicit code prescriptions on acceptable safety levels for progressive collapse scenarios, the proposed framework allows the evaluation of structural robustness in reliability terms and the comparison of different reinforcement configurations under column removal conditions.

Structural reliability of reinforced concrete frames under different column removal scenarios / Miceli, E., De Iuliis, M., Gino, D., Castaldo, P.. - In: STRUCTURES. - ISSN 2352-0124. - 89:(2026). [10.1016/j.istruc.2026.112193]

Structural reliability of reinforced concrete frames under different column removal scenarios

Miceli, Elena;De Iuliis, Massimiliano;Gino, Diego;Castaldo, Paolo
2026

Abstract

This paper presents a reliability assessment of the robustness of reinforced concrete moment-resisting frames subjected to sudden column removal. Two progressive collapse scenarios are considered, involving the loss of a central and a second-to-last supporting column. Three different frame configurations are analysed: a reference frame designed according to current seismic code provisions and two alternative configurations characterized by robustness improvements in the reinforcement detailing. A strain-based five-step procedure is adopted to evaluate the conditional probability of collapse given local damage (i.e., the removal of a supporting column). The methodology combines nonlinear finite-element (NLFE) 2D modelling with a full probabilistic framework, accounting for uncertainties in material properties and applied loads. Latin Hypercube Sampling is employed to generate 100 realizations for each frame configuration and failure scenario, resulting in a total of 600 analyses. Displacement-controlled pushdown NLFE analyses are first performed to derive probabilistic capacity curves, which are subsequently used to compute energy-based dynamic amplification factors through an energetic equivalence approach. Dynamic effects associated with sudden column loss are then reproduced by means of probabilistic static-equivalent NLFE analyses, in which gravity loads acting on the spans adjacent to the removed column are amplified according to the corresponding dynamic amplification factors. Peak strain demands in concrete and reinforcing steel are monitored at critical sections and treated in probabilistic terms. Failure probabilities and corresponding reliability indices at the ultimate limit state are finally evaluated. Given the lack of explicit code prescriptions on acceptable safety levels for progressive collapse scenarios, the proposed framework allows the evaluation of structural robustness in reliability terms and the comparison of different reinforcement configurations under column removal conditions.
File in questo prodotto:
Non ci sono file associati a questo prodotto.
Pubblicazioni consigliate

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11583/3018021
 Attenzione

Attenzione! I dati visualizzati non sono stati sottoposti a validazione da parte dell'ateneo