Urban narcissism vs spatial justice: il capriccio di Little Island a New York

In March 2020, amidst the pandemic emergency, Governor Andrew Cuomo ordered the closure of most construction sites in New York City, except for essential projects. The multi-billion-dollar park project of Little Island was considered as such, prompting reflection on the criteria defining essentiality in urban development during crises. Located in the affluent Meatpacking District, Little Island stands amidst a backdrop of gentrification and elite urban renewal projects like the High Line. Its exclusivity contrasts with underinvested parks in lower-income neighborhoods, highlighting disparities in access to green spaces. The debate surrounding Little Island encapsulates broader discussions on the politics of public space, community representation, and ethical considerations in urban development. As cities evolve, reconciling competing interests and prioritizing equitable access to resources remain central challenges in urban planning.